TILMAN – the final report

(from the Winter 2015 Organic Farming magazine)

Resource explained

This magazine article summarises key messages from research undertaken in the European TILMAN-ORG (Reduced tillage and green manures for sustainable cropping systems) project. It describes some of the background of the project and what inspired it, particularly the perceived incompatibilities of reduced tillage and organic production systems. It explains the methodology used and what analysis of comparison of different tillage methods revealed in relation to crop yield, soil quality and weed population, and the impact of soil type on reduced tillage systems. It refers to outputs from experiments that highlighted the impact of reduced tillage on carbon stocks, soil microbial activity and mycorrhizal fungi. It touches on some key findings in relation to earthworm activity and tillage timing and type. The last section focuses on green manures; farmers finding ways of ensuring adequate nutrient supply to growing crops in reduced tillage systems, what investigations have yielded, and challenges that remain.

Findings & recommendations

  • The project investigated common concerns farmers have about practicing reduced tillage, particularly in relation to weed pressure, incorporating fertility-building leys and compost, and the potential of slowing down the release of nutrients from soils.
  • Analysis of tillage methods showed that yield reductions did not seem to be as great as expected when tillage intensity was reduced.
  • The research revealed that problems with soil structure can develop when lighter soils are managed with reduced tillage.
  • There was no clear relationship found between the effect of reduced tillage on yields and the length of time reduced tillage systems had been implemented.
  • Reducing tillage intensity was found to increase soil microbial activity and diversity. Mycorrhizal fungi were enhanced when tillage was minimised.
  • The article highlighted some startling findings in relation to the impact of reduced tillage on earthworm loss and states that changes to rotation design that involve cultivations when the soil is dry and cold can reduce earthworm losses.
  • Researchers found that yield losses under reduced tillage could be compensated by growth of a green manure before the main crop.
  • The article refers to some innovative green manure and reduced tillage systems being developed and interesting new research being undertaken.


Associated Agricology Partner Organisation(s):

Related articles

Practical recommendations on reduced tillage systems

Video footage of a member of the TILMAN-ORG project outlining some of the problems and potential solutions associated with reduced tillage.

Reduced Tillage: Farmer’s motivations and problems

A video from the TILMAN-ORG project providing useful insights from farmers who have have adopted reduced tillage on their farms.

Reduced tillage trials aim to improve soil sustainability

Interesting results from a 5-year reduced cultivation trial that took place at the Salle Park Estate, Norfolk, to assess the impact of contrasting tillage regimes...

Crop Protection in Reduced Tillage Systems

Pest, weed and disease management in reduced tillage cropping systems; factors to consider and actions you can take.

Economic and ecological benefits of reduced tillage in the UK

A guide to potential benefits and implications of integrating reduced tillage into your farm management system.

The effects of reduced tillage practices and organic material additions on the carbon content of arable soils

A report summaring results from a review which looks at the extent by which reduced tillage practices and organic material returns could increase the organic...

Living Mulches Final Report

The final report for Innovative Farmers field lab trials which aimed to determine the impacts of living mulches on cash crop yields and weed composition.

Reduced till – is it a viable option for organic systems?

Potential benefits and problems with using reduced tillage in organic systems and how it impacts on weed control.

No-till for growers: Part 2 – Soil health practices for growers

Part two of two detailed informal articles looking at the practicalities of applying a no-till system in an organic horticultural operation and how it relates...

Living mulches for sustainable cropping systems: A step towards ‘Regenerative Organic’ Agriculture in the UK?

Reducing tillage and chemical inputs can be beneficial for soil and the environment, so could a permanent clover understorey acting as a 'living mulch', moving...
To top