How to set up a simplified on-farm cultivar trial to assess broccoli?

LIVESEED Practice Abstract No. 8

Resource explained

Most commercial broccoli cultivars originate from conventional breeding and may not perform well under organic conditions. Cultivar trials with a completely randomised block design and 3-4 repetitions are often not feasible for organic farmers. This abstract provides a guide for organic farmers wanting to set up their own on-farm trial – using a simplified cultivar trial with different broccoli varieties. This is one of a series of practice abstracts produced as part of the LIVESEED research project. LIVESEED (Boosting organic seed and plant breeding across Europe) is based on the concept that cultivars adapted to organic systems are key for realising the full potential of organic agriculture in Europe.

Findings & recommendations

  • In order to evaluate differences in varieties, differences in the trial field have to be minimised. This guide suggests planting a reference variety in 2-3 randomly distributed plots and repeating the trial over several years to increase its reliability.
  • When assessing broccoli cultivars it is recommended to assess time of harvest maturity and number of harvests, disease incidences, number of damaged spots, percentage of marketable plants, and weight, size, firmness and colour of heads.
  • Favourable characteristics of broccoli cultivars for organic agriculture include capacity to adapt to lower nitrogen supply, suitability for mechanical weed management, low susceptibility to diseases, and resistance to stress brought on by changes in temperature.


Access the LIVESEED website here. Read about project outcomes and results here.

Summary provided by:

Janie Caldbeck

Associated Agricology Partner Organisation(s):

Related articles

Carrying Out Your Own Farm Trial

How to design an effective field trial – the basics you need to know to help you optimise yields and try out novel farming techniques.

Farm-based organic variety trials

Factsheet based on research undertaken as part of the LIVESEED project detailing an experiment in which wheat varieties were tested by organic farmers at a...

Guide to Farmers’ Crop Trials

This useful guide, published by ADAS, describes the processes leading to successful on-farm trialling while avoiding the possible pitfalls.

Guidelines for on-farm variety testing

A quick reference guide produced as part of the LIVESEED project for farmers interested in carrying out some on-farm variety testing and needing some basic...

Seeds – our culture and our future

Cultivating diversity is one way for smaller organic growers, selling directly to the consumer, to differentiate themselves from the uniform offerings of the multiple retailers....

The seeds of diversity – the challenges of seed supply in extraordinary times

It is great that the pandemic has highlighted for people the importance of their food, which some perhaps previously took for granted. It has meant...
To top